jump to main content
graphic masthead for Goshen Central School District
227 Main Street
Goshen, NY 10924
(845) 615.6720
Roy Reese
Superintendent
link to District Homepage link to Scotchtown Elementary page link to Goshen Intermediate School link to C.J. Hooker Middle School link to Goshen High School
graphic of Noah Webster
graphic of "trotter" logo

Ask the Superintendent - Aug. 23, 2006


On August 7th, Marty Knapp, Board of Education member, Village of Goshen Police Officer, Dare Officer for 12 years, and School Resource Officer, submitted his resignation from the Board of Education effective September 1, 2006. True to form, Officer Marty, as he is affectionately called by many of the Goshen students, was a major contributor at his last Board meeting on Monday, August 21st.

During the last two years, many questions arose as to whether there was a conflict of interest for Marty Knapp to be a member of the Board of Education and to “work” in our schools. There never was a conflict of interest because Marty was never an employee of the school district. His salary was totally paid for through the Village of Goshen. During this summer, Officer Marty’s assignment changed and a portion of his salary was now going to be supplemented by the school district for his role as a School Resource Officer. It became apparent a choice was in the offering. Marty had to decide:

1. Remain a School Resource Officer and resign from the Board of Education;
2. Remain a Board of Education member and resign as the School Resource Officer, and assume a different assignment as a Village of Goshen Police Officer.

It obviously was a difficult choice, because for the past couple of years Marty was a major
resource in our school buildings as well as a valuable member of the Board of Education. Being faced with this decision, Marty opted to resign his seat on the Board of Education and stay with the “kids.” He certainly will be missed as a Board member because he offered important insight in the areas of security, safety and clarity of thinking, all of which were brought about as a result of his many years of police experience.

Marty had ten months remaining in his three-year term of office. His resignation has left the Board with three options:

1. The Board may call for a special election to fill his seat. This would be exactly the same as the election of Board of Education Members and the Annual Budget Vote during the third Tuesday each May. It would require posting four legal notices, filing candidacy petitions and setting aside a day for a special election to fill what would then be approximately eight months of office.

2. The Board of Education can appoint any resident in the community who meets the legal eligibility requirements to fill the open seat:

a. Must be able to read and write;

b. Must be a qualified voter of the district; that is, a citizen of the United States, at least 18 years of age or older, and not adjudged to be incompetent;

c. Must be and have been a resident (but need not be a taxpayer) of the district for a continuous and uninterrupted period of at least one year immediately before the election;

d. May not have been removed from any school district office within the preceding year;

e. May not reside in the same household with another member of the same school board of education;


f. May not be a current employee of the school board; and,

g. May not simultaneously hold another incompatible public office. (School Law, 30th Edition, 2004)

3. The vacant seat may be left unfilled until the next scheduled election in May of 2007.

All three of these possibilities were discussed at the public Board of Education meeting held on Monday, August 21st. Each of these options has advantages and disadvantages. At the meeting, members of the Board expressed strong convictions about spending budgeted funds and concerns about usurping the public’s right to elect members to the Board of Education. They decided to take two weeks to carefully examine each possibility and will make a final determination at the regularly scheduled Board of Education meeting on September 5th.

I personally know how difficult this decision was for Marty. His presence as a Board member will certainly be missed, but fortunately he still remains with our District and will continue to help our students in other ways.

Roy Reese
Superintendent of Schools